When the parking lots are dry I love my Ugg boots but on icy snowy days I used an older version of Merrill snow boots. However, after injuring the peroneal tendon I couldn't wear them, too stiff and too much arch support built into the midsole of the shoe. I got tired of slipping and sliding in the Uggs so I went on a search for new boots. I found this review,
https://www.outdoorgearlab.com/Winter-Boots-Womens-Reviews/ratings, so I used it as my guide. Due to the injury I was particular about too much arch support, stiffness and heel drop which isn't covered in the article. I did get an idea about warmth, waterproofness, etc. Initially I was thinking of buying the Ugg Adirondack II in the kid's version but I couldn't find them to try on and I heard the company has added more support to their shoes.
I went to REI and tried on the Sorel Tivolli II mid snow boot. I loved the look and fit but after wearing it a while my ankle started to complain and I was concerned about the heel height. I also tried on the Merrel Capra Glacial. It would have served my needs for snowshowing but it was very stiff, and had too much support. My ankle started screaming after I had it on for just a few minutes. The best fitting and most comfortable was the Anhu Montera. I wound up buying it for spring and fall hiking. The boot is flexible, doesn't have a lot of arch support, has a fairly low heel to toe drop, fits comfortably over my high instep, is roomy in the toes and is waterproof. I normally wear a 5.5 in running shoes but did size up to a 6. It fits well with my hiking socks. It also comes in a winter version called the Montera Lux winter.
Wearing a hiking boot to plays or out to dinner doesn't quite fit my style so I was still on the search for a winter boot that was less hiking oriented but warm. With my ankle injury I've been pretty happy wearing Clark shoes. This week I got the Clark Tri Arc GTX boots. They are ankle height, made of Goretex, have a decent amount of flex and not much arch support built into them. I'm concerned about the heel-to-toe drop but I'm not planning on hiking in them so we'll see. They are fully lined inside, I did go up a half size but they feel tight with my heavier wool socks. A lighter sock may be all I need due to the warm lining. I'm also not sure how good the traction will be on these.
There is another company called Icebug that specializes in winter boots. The soles are designed specifically for traction on ice and snow. I was really interested in them but the smallest size I could find was a 6.5 so I couldn't tell anything about fit. I also couldn't find any information on heel-toe drop, footbed design etc. so I gave up on that band.
If you look at REI's website under the boot category there is quite a good selection of winter boots. Also, sites like Amazon have very good reviews of boots and shoes.