• Women skiers, this is the place for you -- an online community without the male-orientation you'll find in conventional ski magazines and internet ski forums. At TheSkiDiva.com, you can connect with other women to talk about skiing in a way that you can relate to, about things that you find of interest. Be sure to join our community to participate (women only, please!). Registration is fast and simple. Just be sure to add [email protected] to your address book so your registration activation emails won't be routed as spam. And please give careful consideration to your user name -- it will not be changed once your registration is confirmed.

Salomon Topaz vs Rossingnol Bandit B74

SnownyNorth

Certified Ski Diva
So... I was finally able to demo some skis to replace my Bandit B2s, but it really came down to only two choices. The ski shop would not let me trade up to a special order, so it was only shop stock available. They also only stock 148/150's or 160's for the women's skis- nothing inbetween.
I am 5'6", 147 lbs, and 46, intermediate skiier.
So here goes- this is all feel, no technical jargon- sorry.
The conditions varied from hard pack to ice, to frozen crust powder, to sublime sugar.
I took the Salomons out first in 150cm. Even though the thirteen year old with us thought they were cool, I really was distracted by gaggy flowers. The edge was the hardest thing to get used to- they cut so deep into the surface it was really hard to control the turns, and on ice were stuck in their own grooves. Small turns were easy, but grabby, and larger turns nicer. At higher speeds they became chattery and the edges seemed to slice and catch.
When I switched to the Bandit B74's, they seemed so much longer, and I was worried. Length seems to be such a huge issue with everyone, so I went by feel alone. Instantly I felt like I had more control and by the third run I was happily in and out of the little powdery side trails and dips. They were great on hard ice chunks and polished ice (by day's end). Not too grippy, and easy to turn. I actually started having fun. The best thing about these skiis is that all my old habits from the old ski days were forgiven if they snuck in. I found myself more relaxed and not trying so hard.
So, as my only choices for the exchange, I went with the Rossi B74's- not thinking I would ever like a Rossingnol ski. I wonder how much difference a 155 would have made in either ski. Oh well I am now set, and really, nothing is forever.
I am off to Smithers this Thursday- we'll see how that fares.
 

Jilly

Moderator
Staff member
Should have tried the Salomon in 160. They do like to carve, for an all-mountain ski. But if you're skiing interior BC, you're going to like the B74's better.
 

SnownyNorth

Certified Ski Diva
I was really hoping to try the Salomons in a 160, but the 150's were all they had- really too bad my husband (although thoughtful) comitted to that shop when he bought the Bandit B2s. I now know length makes a big difference. Most of my skiing is local BC interior with mountain trips mostly to Jasper. I haven't skiied PowderKing yet- the die hard powder hounds were even saying it was just too deep this past week. The shop also had K2's Lotta Luv (too much ski for me I think), and the TrueLuvs were sold out.
 

lucine

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Try the Lotta luvs, you may find that they are NOT too much ski for you.
If you have em available, you may always wonder.

Good Luck
 

SkiGirly

Diva in Training
I have demoed the Topaz and I absolutely loved them. They were so smooth compared to all the others that I tried. I got to demo next year's as well and they are the same just with a better top sheet.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
27,588
Messages
526,870
Members
9,722
Latest member
ruby.aitken
Top