• Women skiers, this is the place for you -- an online community without the male-orientation you'll find in conventional ski magazines and internet ski forums. At TheSkiDiva.com, you can connect with other women to talk about skiing in a way that you can relate to, about things that you find of interest. Be sure to join our community to participate (women only, please!). Registration is fast and simple. Just be sure to add webmaster@theskidiva.com to your address book so your registration activation emails won't be routed as spam. And please give careful consideration to your user name -- it will not be changed once your registration is confirmed.

Back protection: when is it worth it?

Amplify

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Any thoughts on back protection like the Pocito, for kids at least?

I never even thought about it until my 11-year old had a scary fall landing in an unfamiliar terrain park a while ago. The drop from the jump was steeper than expected and he landed almost on his tips, then ejected from his skis, flipped forward, and kind of somersaulted mid-air, landing on his upper back. It got me thinking - both of my kids are the sort to jump off of ANYTHING they can find. They are not reckless skiers and they do not chase speed for the sake of it, but they are good skiers and on steep terrain they do end up going fast. They aren’t into tricks like flips etc (yet lol) but they love jumping off stuff, zipping around in the glades, bouncing through mogul fields, etc.

I know that many severe injuries people sustain skiing are not injuries that a helmet will do much for. And so I find myself wondering if back/spine protection is reasonable? Or if it’s like…overkill?

When I was a kid NOBODY wore helmets and then when I was maybe in my 20s I saw a few people with helmets but the general attitude was still kind of in “lol next thing people will be wearing helmets just to walk around town” territory. And now I almost never see someone skiing without a helmet (thank goodness! It seems wild to me that my parents just sent me off down a mountain with no helmet lol, but they also would fold down the back seats and fill the station wagon with blankets for our 6-hour road trips to the ski mountain, for us to just lay down and roll around/nap/etc - so obviously it was a different time!)

I have heard that the Pocito back brace is very comfortable and so I’m wondering - is it, like, the next step towards reasonable safety measures like helmets once were? Or am I just overthinking and over-worrying?

Just interested in anyone else’s thoughts on the subject.
 
What about putting the kiddo's into a some sort of "all mountain" session group. More of a free-ride, than park. They might learn how "not" to certain things.
 
That’s on my list to look into for next year! They are not competitive and don’t want to race etc which I am fine with lol. And they are good skiers and not reckless - my oldest was informed about “junior instructor lessons” by a coach at our local mountain; he dreams of being ski patrol someday haha - so while they do like skiing in ways that feel moderately risky to me, they are not reckless or “risk seeking” if that makes sense. I just find myself wondering sometimes like, where the boundary is as far as which types of additional protection are reasonable and which aren’t.
 
I saw more than one type of back protector in the ski shops in Chamonix last April (sightseeing trip mostly). Saw a few men and boys wearing one. Presumably for skiing off-piste among rocks more than for terrain parks since those aren't a fixture as they are at American ski areas/resorts.
 
I got everyone (even me) back protectors this season bec everyone is skiing more agressively now. My younger daughter has been good with complying but my older daughter will find any excuse to skip it…
 
Interesting question. We need an ER dr from a ski town here to tell us if the injuries it protects us from are injuries we are likely to sustain on the slopes.
 
Yes exactly! I am like, "Is this likely to actually protect from an injury that skiers might experience outside of a total freak accident? or nah?" Like we can't just be in bubbles all the time "just in case." But that's what everybody used to say about helmets, too.

I feel like knee injuries are the main risk as far as actual injury - but I also feel like that's more for, like, me/adults. For my kids I don't really think about their knees at all. I feel like my big worries are: adult-size people crashing into them at high speeds; having an otherwise "routine" fall turn serious ie hitting a patch of ice on super-steep terrain and sliding into a snow gun or something; taking a certain type of fall on rocky terrain. But I can't tell if those worries are just feels or if they have some reality behind them.
 
Yes exactly! I am like, "Is this likely to actually protect from an injury that skiers might experience outside of a total freak accident? or nah?" Like we can't just be in bubbles all the time "just in case." But that's what everybody used to say about helmets, too.
Instead of getting a back protector, I'd be more inclined to make sure a kid learned the better approach when starting to fall. Park lessons sounds like a good idea. Keep in mind that given my personality the way I dealt with continuing to ski without an ACL was to invest in lessons, as opposed to a knee brace.

Have you ever looked at Vermont Safety for tips on how to avoid knee injuries? In particular, ACL injuries. The main premise is that falling backwards is a bad idea.
 
I have never seen the Vermont Safety tips! Thank you for that!

I appreciate your point - I remember years ago reading some data that suggested that in sports that have standardized increasingly protective gear (helmets, padding, etc) the injury rate often increased over time, or at least didn't go down, or maybe minor injuries decreased but major injuries increased - it was some sort of potential result that was counterintuitive. The hypothesis was that adding increasingly protective gear can subconsciously alter behavior around movement, aggression in gameplay, etc. Risk compensation, basically.
 
Here are a couple articles about the most common injuries for skiers. Of course, most skiers aren't in terrain parks. Plus any data is often for people ages 16 and up, as opposed to 10-15. My academic and professional background is as a biostatistician, so I always consider the population being studied from at least a gender and age basis.



Found this study for children from 2019 by researchers based in Colorado. They reviewed 70 studies reported in English. A few of the references cited are over 20 years old, so may or may not reflect the current state of skiing by children in the 2020s. I would expect regional differences between regions like the Rockies with big mountains or the midwest that has short slopes and lots of terrain parks.

Pediatric and Adolescent Injury in Skiing
published by the Sports Medicine Center of Children's Hospital Colorado
" . . .
Terrain parks, jumps, half-pipe and rails are also associated with the highest prevalence of injury and incidence of severe injuries (fractures of any type or location, concussions, ruptures, sprains, strains, and dislocations)
. . ."
 
I have never seen the Vermont Safety tips! Thank you for that!

I appreciate your point - I remember years ago reading some data that suggested that in sports that have standardized increasingly protective gear (helmets, padding, etc) the injury rate often increased over time, or at least didn't go down, or maybe minor injuries decreased but major injuries increased - it was some sort of potential result that was counterintuitive. The hypothesis was that adding increasingly protective gear can subconsciously alter behavior around movement, aggression in gameplay, etc. Risk compensation, basically.
There’s a lot of talk surrounding that in equestrian sports, where some (racing, three day eventing) require back protectors (they’re more vest-like and also offer some protection to the ribs). Because they’re required, they’re available on the market, and due to accessibility they’re becoming more prevalent across the sport regardless of discipline, and a lot of folks seem to use them as an “excuse” to do riskier things. ‘Oh, I have my back protector on, so we can absolutely raise the height of the jumps. Never mind my horse and I don’t have the skills for that.’ That sort of thing.
 
My son (17) has started to wear his mountain biking chest/back protector when he's planning to practice rails in the park. He said it doesn't interfere with his other skiing. I'm not sure how much protection it would offer from falls off a jump, but I can definitely see the benefit from impact with rails!
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
27,762
Messages
531,522
Members
9,787
Latest member
ndmb
Back
Top