• Women skiers, this is the place for you -- an online community without the male-orientation you'll find in conventional ski magazines and internet ski forums. At TheSkiDiva.com, you can connect with other women to talk about skiing in a way that you can relate to, about things that you find of interest. Be sure to join our community to participate (women only, please!). Registration is fast and simple. Just be sure to add [email protected] to your address book so your registration activation emails won't be routed as spam. And please give careful consideration to your user name -- it will not be changed once your registration is confirmed.

ACL tears occur more in women.

ski diva

Administrator
Staff member
According to an article in this week's Time magazine, ACL tears occur at least twice as often -- and in some sports up to 8 times as often -- in female athletes as in male athletes.

Researchers at the Cleveland Clinic studied how these injuries happen and how they differ in men and women, and they found that when athletes start jumping, the women are more likely to land on their feet in ways that make them ore vulnerable to ACL tears. The distance between their knees is narrower, the ankle is more flexed, and the foot rolls outward more.

They haven't figured out why women land the way they do -- just that they tear their ACL's more. So be careful out there!
 

Pequenita

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Key things are: (1) Quads and hamstrings don't always fire simultaneously in women. Simultaneous firing of the muscles leads to knee joint stability. (2) It's arguable that womens' knees are just not as stable as men's, thanks to the angle (generated by the width of the hips) at which the femur meets the lower leg bones. (3) Also, due to hormone fluctuation during the month, ligaments are more prone to hyperextension during one's menses. I actually try to plan ski trips around this, or take it easy on certain days.

I've a whole stack of literature on this if anyone is interested....
 

Lola

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
When my ACL was destroyed last year, my surgeon said that this type of injury is much more common in women. However, like Little Lightning, I recovered exceedingly well and was skiing again in nine months. So, while it may be more common, we are - after all - women. And I think women recouperate from major health issues better than men because we are stronger and we don't whine and cry as much as our male counterparts. :smile: Oh, and I also followed my surgeon's instructions.
Just my two cents. ~ Lola
 

Pequenita

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Okay - just so it's out there, I'm not a physician or PT and don't work in the health care field. I just know this stuff because I've gone through 2 surgeries related to the same ACL, and the second time, I found an awesome doc whose specialty is knee injuries in women. This was in 2003. He gave me a stack of academic journal articles reporting findings from studies on women's knee injuries. Since then, whenever I've been bored at work, I do Lexis/Nexis journal searches on ACL tears and women.

The interesting thing, to me, is that the ACL stabilizes the joint to facilitate the lateral cutting motion, but, as SkiDiva's post re: Time magazine points out, more women than men rupture their ACLs by merely jumping. That's right - no contact injuries. One study* concluded that there are 8 special considerations for female athletes:
(1) women are a little knock-kneed; (2) women use their quads to stabilize the knee joint instead of the hamstrings, which are more efficient. We generally also have stronger quads than hamstrings; (3) our reaction times (and therefore, the generation of muscular force) is slower than those of men; (4) women frequently lose control of their hips and trunks after landing a jump, for example, landing a jump, turning the knees inward, and body falling laterally across the legs; (5) I don't really understand this one, and to me, it and #4 seem to be more of a core strength issue (which I don't think was quite in vogue when the article was published) -- but #5 is that hip musculature should be engaged to help stabilize the knee; (6) women have more knee laxity in general (well, in general, we're more flexible than guys); therefore, we frequently hyperextend our knees. This article seems to believe that women tend to land from jumps straight-legged. I can't see how that can be comfortable...but then again, I am the least flexible person in my yoga class. One should land jumps with bent knees; landing with legs in full extension makes the stabilizing muscles less efficient. Also, along the same lines of laxity, the first day of the menses tends to correlate with the day that ligaments are their most lax in a woman; (7) the female athletes in the test group tended to have decreased neuromuscular control of their legs, ie, less efficient stabilization patterns. I think wobble board training can fix this one; (8) female athletes in the study had decreased muscular endurance as compared to men.

This article is a little old - the newer literature that I've read tends to focus predominantly on the timing of the recruitment of the hamstrings. I just quickly skimmed the JAT article from 2004 that Little Lightning posted, and it seems to follow up on the study that I'm citing from. Also some nice pix showing what they mean! Even though these findings concern no-contact ACL injuries, I think they remain good things to keep in mind. Strong knees are sexy. :D


* "Rehabilitation After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in the Female Athlete," Kevin E. Wilk, et al. Journal of Athletic Training, vol 34. no. 2, June 1999, pp 177-193.
 

altagirl

Moderator
Staff member
I've read that too - that women are more prone to knee injury because they jump and land incorrectly. But none of my 4 knee surgeries were from jumping, they were all twisting/cutting type movements. My current surgeon drilled out part of my intercondylar (I think I just butchered the spelling) notch, which he said was rubbing on my original ACL - so genetically, my knees weren't set up for success with bone rubbing on the ligaments. I haven't had any repeat ACL injuries - just one ACL reconstruction on each knee, and one meniscus surgery on each knee.
 

volklgirl

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
I read some research on injured women basketball players recently.....they're also finding that women have a differently shaped tunnel that the ACL travels through. Compared to men, it's more narrow and pointy-shaped, making contact with and rupture of the ACL more likely under impact.
 

Lisamarie

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Here is a chapter excerpt I wrote about this:

Some people can participate in a sport for years, and never damage their ACL. Others have had three or four ACL reconstructions. What determines susceptibility?

1. You are female. This is not a sexist statement. Statistics don’t lie. If you are female, you are probably asking “Why Me?” The following factors contribute to a woman’s susceptibility to ACL injury:
• “Q” Angle: The Q angle refers to the quadriceps angle, or the angle between the hip and the knee. Since it is steeper in women, they are more prone to having the kneecap slide, thereby causing injury.
• Less Androgen: Having less androgen means that women are often less prone to developing large muscles. Muscle fiber helps protect the joints and connective tissue. Female athletes are subject to the same torque forces in their knee as men. If the muscle is not strong enough to protect the joint, the kneecap will be even more prone to sliding.
• Jump Landing Tactics: Women do not bend their knees as much as men when landing from a jump. This increases knee joint pressure.
• Pivoting Tactics: Women turn and pivot in a more erect position. Bending at the knee and hip reduces ACL stress.
• Quadricep/Hamstring Imbalance: Women use their quads more then their hamstrings when landing and changing direction. As the quadriceps contract, the hamstrings will stretch and relax. A stretched muscle produces less force. If the knee is not sufficiently flexed, there will be increased force on the shinbone. This can cause an ACL tear. It’s extremely important to realize that anyone, male or female, whose quadricep muscles are significantly stronger than their hamstrings, may be highly susceptible to ACL injury!
• Narrow Intercondylar Notch: This is a controversial theory, but worth examining. The intercondylar notch is at the end of the thigh. . This is where the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments form an x. It has been speculated that since women have a narrow notch, it predisposes them to ACL injury.
• Estrogen and Joint Laxity: The female hormones often give women natural joint and muscular flexibility. Unfortunately, this often leads to hyper mobility. The current trend towards extreme yoga practices that encourage contortion, as opposed to functional, dynamic flexibility may be one of the key reasons that women are suffering more ACL injuries. Keep in mind, there has been no study whatsoever that has successfully concluded that pre-sport stretching prevents injury, but many studies have demonstrated that excessive pre-activity stretching can actually cause injury. In 1988, a Swedish study of 108 female soccer players demonstrated that the players were more susceptible to injury during the premenstrual and menstrual stages of their cycles. It’s interesting to note that injuries were reduced when oral contraceptives were administrated.
2. Foot factors: A common phrase used in sports medicine is “Don’t just look at the site of the crash.” In the case of an ACL tear, the muscles around the knee are not the only ones to be considered. You also need to take a look at the feet. The three most common foot factors related to ACL injury are
• Pronation
• Limited Dorsi flexion (ability to curl toes towards shin)
• Flat footed

Landing flat-footed form a jump can cause ACL injury. The proper landing progression is Toe
Ball
Heel
Squat
3. Lack of Neuromuscular Coordination: Even recreational athletes with minimal muscular imbalances may be susceptible to ACL tears due to faulty muscular firing patterns. The hamstrings may be strong, but if they don’t fire at the exact right moment, they will not protect the ACL. Sport conditioning experts often use the phrase, “Train the Chain.” This refers to the kinetic chain, which describes the sequence of muscular contractions in any movement pattern. Cutting edge sport fitness professionals seek out training patterns that mimic the kinetic chain sequences of specific sports.
4. Insufficient Balance and Stability: Prior to any foot strike, your deep core muscles must to stabilize the sacroiliac (SI) joint. If this does not happen, the SI joint is destabilized, causing a misalignment of the femurs connection to the pelvis, which in turn misaligns the knee.
5. Lack of Proprioception: Proprioception refers to the awareness of your body’s position in space. Poor proprioception will make you unaware of the terrain below your feet. This lack of awareness can cause you to misjudge your movement patterns, thereby setting you up for injury.
6. Tight Hip Flexors: Tight hip flexors are usually accompanied by a weak gluteus. If your gluteus is weak, your quadriceps need to work harder, which in turn causes a hamstring/quadriceps imbalance, which sets you up for injury.
7. Tight Illiotibial Band: The IT band runs down the side of your leg. If it’s tight, it inhibits the workings of the vatsus medialis, which is the muscle above the knee responsible for correct knee tracking. Incorrect knee tracking can cause injury.
8. Weak Eccentric Strength: Since ACL injuries happen in the eccentric or lengthening phase of muscular contraction, lack of eccentric strength can cause injury.
9. Poor Technique and Malfunctioning Equipment: Even if none of the above factors are present, poor technique and malfunctioning equipment can lead to ACL injury. The Vermont Ski Safety Association has outlined the key technical faults that set a skier up for injury:
• Attempting to get up while still moving after a fall.
• Attempting a recovery from an off-balance position.
• Attempting to sit down after losing control.
• Uphill arm back.
• Skier off-balance to the rear.
• Hips below the knees.
• Uphill ski unweighted.
• Weight on the inside edge of downhill ski tail. Upper body generally facing downhill ski.
Prevention Plan
If you are a serious recreational athlete, your first step is to find a certified fitness professional that specializes in sport conditioning, and postural alignment analysis. Pilates instructors as well as instructors certified by The National Academy of Sports Medicine are usually your best bet. These professionals will create programs based on your specific misalignments and muscular imbalances. Make sure that your trainer pays particular attention to your pelvic, knee and foot alignment, since these areas have the greatest influence on the ACL. Should you choose to create your own program, there are a number of things to consider.
Train Barefoot: At least sometimes. It’s no surprise that dancers and martial artists, who train barefoot, have the lowest incidence of ACL tears. Skiers, whose boots restrict proprioception, have the highest. Since martial arts forms such as judo teach its participants how to fall, such classes can be effective for cross training.
Integrate Strength Training With Balance: Devices such as the stability ball, wobble board, dyna disc, Bosu etc. are used by the top athletic teams. You should use them too.
Work Your Hamstrings: Review the Stability Ball Hamstring Curl in Chapter 8. This is one of the best hamstring exercises for snow sliders!
Avoid the Leg Extension Machine: This machine can apply shearing forces to the knee, making it more susceptible to ACL injury.
Practice “Closed Chain” Exercise: Closed Chain exercises keep your foot in a closed position, i.e., in contact with the floor. This incorporates the use of more muscle groups, while lessening the shearing forces on the knee present in open chain exercises such as the leg extension. Examples of closed chain exercises are the squat and the leg press.
Practice Plyometrics: Plyometrics teach participants proper jump landing mechanisms. Since this involves landing with knees flexed, plyometrics are an excellent way to achieve sufficient hamstring strength.
While many people refer to sport conditioning as “off season training,” this is a big mistake. Conditioning should be a year-round event. Unfortunately, even the best conditioning program will not protect you from ACL injury if your athletic technique is insufficient, and/or your equipment is not working properly. You can be an excellent skier, but if you are practicing your sport at the end of the day, when most sport injuries occur, you may still be injured. Checking your equipment is also crucial. A binding that fails to release can turn a benign fall into a serious injury.
 

pinto

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Very interesting. I've been knocking on wood for many years. I played years of soccer, at a pretty high level, which is a sport just rife with ACL injuries. And I ski, a lot. My knees aren't great, but it's almost all tracking/patellar issues, and I've never ever had a ligament injury. I've wondered if it's just been dumb luck or what.

Looking at the list, the things that stick out (at least for skiing) are first, I have always been able to judge when to let a fall happen and when I can get out of it. I don't think I've ever tried to recover from a fall and failed. I can't say why this is ... I'm not going to think about it. It seems that my body knows when I need to let it go and when I can recover. And when I let it go, I mean it. FLOP. Just relax and enjoy the ride. (Okay, you can't do this in certain places, but then you just can't fall.)

The other is that I don't have backseat problems.

And I play a lot of tennis, with a lot of footwork and cutting and stopping and starting (sort of like soccer was), and that seems to really help my proprioception and balance.
 

Pequenita

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
pinto said:
I have always been able to judge when to let a fall happen and when I can get out of it. I don't think I've ever tried to recover from a fall and failed.

I think that's a great instinct to have, which I lack. Case in point: a week before ACL surgery, I tripped down the steps. Instead of letting myself fall, I tried to save it, and hyper extended and popped a ligament in my ankle (in the leg not being operated on). Any normal person would have been like, "Oh, I'm going over my toes, this is not good." I, on the other hand, thought, "Oh, I'm going over my toes....my feet are strong enough to stop this. Ow."
 

marzNC

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Angel Diva
bump

Was thinking of starting a thread about ACL injury prevention, but thought I'd look at the archives first.
 

marzNC

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Angel Diva
Here is a chapter excerpt I wrote about this:

Some people can participate in a sport for years, and never damage their ACL. Others have had three or four ACL reconstructions. What determines susceptibility?

1. You are female. This is not a sexist statement. Statistics don’t lie. If you are female, you are probably asking “Why Me?” The following factors contribute to a woman’s susceptibility to ACL injury:
• “Q” Angle: The Q angle refers to the quadriceps angle, or the angle between the hip and the knee. Since it is steeper in women, they are more prone to having the kneecap slide, thereby causing injury.
• Less Androgen: Having less androgen means that women are often less prone to developing large muscles. Muscle fiber helps protect the joints and connective tissue. Female athletes are subject to the same torque forces in their knee as men. If the muscle is not strong enough to protect the joint, the kneecap will be even more prone to sliding.
• Jump Landing Tactics: Women do not bend their knees as much as men when landing from a jump. This increases knee joint pressure.
• Pivoting Tactics: Women turn and pivot in a more erect position. Bending at the knee and hip reduces ACL stress.
• Quadricep/Hamstring Imbalance: Women use their quads more then their hamstrings when landing and changing direction. As the quadriceps contract, the hamstrings will stretch and relax. A stretched muscle produces less force. If the knee is not sufficiently flexed, there will be increased force on the shinbone. This can cause an ACL tear. It’s extremely important to realize that anyone, male or female, whose quadricep muscles are significantly stronger than their hamstrings, may be highly susceptible to ACL injury!
• Narrow Intercondylar Notch: This is a controversial theory, but worth examining. The intercondylar notch is at the end of the thigh. . This is where the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments form an x. It has been speculated that since women have a narrow notch, it predisposes them to ACL injury.
• Estrogen and Joint Laxity: The female hormones often give women natural joint and muscular flexibility. Unfortunately, this often leads to hyper mobility. The current trend towards extreme yoga practices that encourage contortion, as opposed to functional, dynamic flexibility may be one of the key reasons that women are suffering more ACL injuries. Keep in mind, there has been no study whatsoever that has successfully concluded that pre-sport stretching prevents injury, but many studies have demonstrated that excessive pre-activity stretching can actually cause injury. In 1988, a Swedish study of 108 female soccer players demonstrated that the players were more susceptible to injury during the premenstrual and menstrual stages of their cycles. It’s interesting to note that injuries were reduced when oral contraceptives were administrated.
2. Foot factors: A common phrase used in sports medicine is “Don’t just look at the site of the crash.” In the case of an ACL tear, the muscles around the knee are not the only ones to be considered. You also need to take a look at the feet. The three most common foot factors related to ACL injury are
• Pronation
• Limited Dorsi flexion (ability to curl toes towards shin)
• Flat footed

Landing flat-footed form a jump can cause ACL injury. The proper landing progression is Toe
Ball
Heel
Squat
3. Lack of Neuromuscular Coordination: Even recreational athletes with minimal muscular imbalances may be susceptible to ACL tears due to faulty muscular firing patterns. The hamstrings may be strong, but if they don’t fire at the exact right moment, they will not protect the ACL. Sport conditioning experts often use the phrase, “Train the Chain.” This refers to the kinetic chain, which describes the sequence of muscular contractions in any movement pattern. Cutting edge sport fitness professionals seek out training patterns that mimic the kinetic chain sequences of specific sports.
4. Insufficient Balance and Stability: Prior to any foot strike, your deep core muscles must to stabilize the sacroiliac (SI) joint. If this does not happen, the SI joint is destabilized, causing a misalignment of the femurs connection to the pelvis, which in turn misaligns the knee.
5. Lack of Proprioception: Proprioception refers to the awareness of your body’s position in space. Poor proprioception will make you unaware of the terrain below your feet. This lack of awareness can cause you to misjudge your movement patterns, thereby setting you up for injury.
6. Tight Hip Flexors: Tight hip flexors are usually accompanied by a weak gluteus. If your gluteus is weak, your quadriceps need to work harder, which in turn causes a hamstring/quadriceps imbalance, which sets you up for injury.
7. Tight Illiotibial Band: The IT band runs down the side of your leg. If it’s tight, it inhibits the workings of the vatsus medialis, which is the muscle above the knee responsible for correct knee tracking. Incorrect knee tracking can cause injury.
8. Weak Eccentric Strength: Since ACL injuries happen in the eccentric or lengthening phase of muscular contraction, lack of eccentric strength can cause injury.
9. Poor Technique and Malfunctioning Equipment: Even if none of the above factors are present, poor technique and malfunctioning equipment can lead to ACL injury. The Vermont Ski Safety Association has outlined the key technical faults that set a skier up for injury:
• Attempting to get up while still moving after a fall.
• Attempting a recovery from an off-balance position.
• Attempting to sit down after losing control.
• Uphill arm back.
• Skier off-balance to the rear.
• Hips below the knees.
• Uphill ski unweighted.
• Weight on the inside edge of downhill ski tail. Upper body generally facing downhill ski.
Prevention Plan
If you are a serious recreational athlete, your first step is to find a certified fitness professional that specializes in sport conditioning, and postural alignment analysis. Pilates instructors as well as instructors certified by The National Academy of Sports Medicine are usually your best bet. These professionals will create programs based on your specific misalignments and muscular imbalances. Make sure that your trainer pays particular attention to your pelvic, knee and foot alignment, since these areas have the greatest influence on the ACL. Should you choose to create your own program, there are a number of things to consider.
Train Barefoot: At least sometimes. It’s no surprise that dancers and martial artists, who train barefoot, have the lowest incidence of ACL tears. Skiers, whose boots restrict proprioception, have the highest. Since martial arts forms such as judo teach its participants how to fall, such classes can be effective for cross training.
Integrate Strength Training With Balance: Devices such as the stability ball, wobble board, dyna disc, Bosu etc. are used by the top athletic teams. You should use them too.
Work Your Hamstrings: Review the Stability Ball Hamstring Curl in Chapter 8. This is one of the best hamstring exercises for snow sliders!
Avoid the Leg Extension Machine: This machine can apply shearing forces to the knee, making it more susceptible to ACL injury.
Practice “Closed Chain” Exercise: Closed Chain exercises keep your foot in a closed position, i.e., in contact with the floor. This incorporates the use of more muscle groups, while lessening the shearing forces on the knee present in open chain exercises such as the leg extension. Examples of closed chain exercises are the squat and the leg press.
Practice Plyometrics: Plyometrics teach participants proper jump landing mechanisms. Since this involves landing with knees flexed, plyometrics are an excellent way to achieve sufficient hamstring strength.
While many people refer to sport conditioning as “off season training,” this is a big mistake. Conditioning should be a year-round event. Unfortunately, even the best conditioning program will not protect you from ACL injury if your athletic technique is insufficient, and/or your equipment is not working properly. You can be an excellent skier, but if you are practicing your sport at the end of the day, when most sport injuries occur, you may still be injured. Checking your equipment is also crucial. A binding that fails to release can turn a benign fall into a serious injury.

Lisa Marie is the author of LifeTips 101 Womens Fitness Tips.

https://www.amazon.com/LifeTips-101...1492637?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1192821602&sr=8-1
 

marzNC

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Angel Diva
This article in ESPN-W from June 2011 describes primary factors that can be used to assess the level of risk a female athlete has towards ACL injury.

https://w.espn.go.com/espnw/training/6660099/how-avoid-acl-injury

There is an organization called Girls Can Jump that promotes ACL prevention techniques, especially for girls playing sports like soccer and basketball. There are 8 factors including quad dominance and glut strength. The factors are described in a sidebar in the article.

The article has a link to an app designed by an orthopedic surgeon at the Univ. of Pittsburg to help an athlete stick with an ACL injury prevention program like PEP or Sportsmetrics. The basic exercises are described at the end of the article. The good news is that teams that use something like PEP reduce the number of ACL injuries significantly. Apparently it takes 6-8 weeks of PEP 3-4 times a week for the differences to be ingrained.

Be nice if someone would do something similar for skiers.
 

VickiK

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Angel Diva
Good bump! Sounds like the full or abbreviated PEP plan would work for any sport.
 

marzNC

Ski Diva Extraordinaire
Angel Diva
Found a new reference about the association between menstrual cycle and ACL injury. The results of a retrospective study done by French researchers was published in the June 2013 issue of a medical journal. Here is an overview in a blog on Women's Sports Injury by the Univ. of Washington:

https://womenssportsmedicine.blogspot.com/2013/06/acl-injury-and-menstrual-cycle.html

"Bottom Line: The findings suggest that women engaged in risky recreational exercise during the pre-ovulatory stage of their menstrual cycles could decrease their risk of injury by taking special precautions. In skiing this might involve skiing on less demanding runs and adjusting release bindings to a lower threshold."
 

altagirl

Moderator
Staff member
Found a new reference about the association between menstrual cycle and ACL injury. The results of a retrospective study done by French researchers was published in the June 2013 issue of a medical journal. Here is an overview in a blog on Women's Sports Injury by the Univ. of Washington:

https://womenssportsmedicine.blogspot.com/2013/06/acl-injury-and-menstrual-cycle.html

"Bottom Line: The findings suggest that women engaged in risky recreational exercise during the pre-ovulatory stage of their menstrual cycles could decrease their risk of injury by taking special precautions. In skiing this might involve skiing on less demanding runs and adjusting release bindings to a lower threshold."

I agree with taking precautions to decrease risk, but lowing your binding release just seems like asking to cause other injuries. Despite all my knee injuries, none of them were from a ski not releasing when it should have. But I've injured other parts of my body walking out of demo bindings when they should not have released.

I guess I just question the logic. If you're going to be careful, be careful. Thinking you're being more "safe" by lowering your DIN on certain days? That makes no sense to me.
 

Skisailor

Angel Diva
I agree with Altagirl. I've been very lucky on the injury front over the years, but my much scarier near misses have come from premature release of demo bindings (and in one case, aging bindings) rather than from failure of a ski to release during a fall.

Ever since, I've been careful to make sure I'm not skiing with a DIN setting that's too low.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
27,558
Messages
526,346
Members
9,690
Latest member
Lorri A
Top